Policy for communicating penalties and undertakings
First published as revised Word document: March 2022
Created as a webpage: November 2026
Purpose
This guidance has been published to explain our approach to publishing information about penalties which have been issued by us and undertakings which have been accepted by us.
It aims to make clear:
what information we will publish
when we will publish that information
where we will publish that information
in which circumstances and how we might publicise penalties and undertakings
We also set out the situations when information will not or might not be published by us. This document relates to:
fixed and variable monetary penalties and non-compliance penalties which have been issued by us, costs recovery notices issued by us, and enforcement and variable monetary penalty undertakings which have been accepted by us under the Environmental Regulation (Enforcement Measures)(Scotland) Order 2015
civil penalties under the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme Regulations 2012 and the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme Order 2020 (ETS), the Energy Savings Opportunities Scheme Regulations 2014 (ESOS), the Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases Regulations 2015 (F-GAS) and The Air Navigation (Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation) Order 2021 (CORSIA) (together “the Climate Change Civil Penalties”)
fixed penalty notices under the Transfrontier Shipment of Waste Regulations 2007
Background: Publication
Enforcement action is a key part of our Regulatory Strategy and allows us to improve compliance levels, tackle environmental crime and drive behaviours in a positive direction. We want our enforcement activities to deter and discourage offenders and for these to be fairly, consistently and proportionately applied alongside our other regulatory work, including audits, inspections and monitoring activities.
The courses of enforcement action available are now broad and span serious offending that will continue to be reported by us for consideration for prosecution by the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and lower-level offences that we will deal with directly, via new enforcement measures intended to address non-compliant activity and poor performance.
This policy complements our Enforcement Policy and explains what we will do to communicate penalties and undertakings.
We are required under the Environmental Regulation (Enforcement Measures) (Scotland) Order 2015 (the Order) to publish the number and type of cases in which fixed monetary penalties, variable monetary penalties, non-compliance penalties and costs recovery notices have been imposed, and the number and type of cases in which a variable monetary penalty undertaking (VMP undertaking), or enforcement undertaking has been accepted by us.
We have also been given the discretion by the Order to publish, in such manner as we think fit:
final fixed monetary penalty notices imposed by us
final variable monetary penalty notices imposed by us
non-compliance penalty notices imposed by us
VMP undertakings accepted by us
enforcement undertakings accepted by us
We are also required to publish some information about some civil penalties under the ETS, F-GAS and ESOS.
We have undertaken, in terms of our Guidance on the use of enforcement action, to publish information about fixed monetary penalties, variable monetary penalties and non-compliance penalties issued and undertakings accepted by us.
We may also, in terms of that guidance, publicise the use of particular enforcement actions in other ways when we consider it appropriate to secure one or more of our enforcement outcomes – to achieve the behaviour change that will effectively protect and, where possible, improve the environment, secure the well-being of people in Scotland and contribute to the sustainable use of resources.
Summary: What information will we publish
Type of enforcement action
Including fixed penalties issued by us under the Transfrontier Shipment of Waste Regulation 2007.
What we publish:
number of penalties, type of cases and total amount of penalties
name/partial address*, date penalty issued, details of offence and penalty amount
all notices issued*
Where we will publish:
We will publish:
number of penalties, type of cases and total amount of penalties
Where we will publish:
UK Emissions trading scheme web page
What we will publish:
name/partial address*, date penalty issued, details of the failure resulting in a penalty and penalty amount
all notices issued (except for civil penalties under ETS)*
Where we will publish:
UK Emissions trading scheme web page
What we will publish:
number of penalties, type of cases and total amount of penalties
name/partial address*, date penalty issued, details of offence and penalty amount
all final notices*
Where we will publish:
What we will publish:
number of undertakings and type of cases
name/partial address*, date undertaking accepted and details of offence
copies of all undertakings accepted (offer, acceptance and any related correspondence or notices)
Where we will publish:
enforcement penalty web page
What we will publish:
number of undertakings and type of cases
name/partial address**, date undertaking accepted, details of offence and any non-compliance certificates issued
copies of all undertakings accepted (offer, acceptance and any related correspondence or notices)**
Where we will publish:
What we publish:
number of penalties, type of cases and total amount of penalties
name/partial address*, date of offence and penalty amount
all penalty notices*
Where we will publish:
What we publish:
number of notices, type of cases and total amount of costs
name/partial address**, date notice issued and amount of the costs to be paid
Where we will publish:
*For penalties issued after 1 March 2022, names and partial addresses of individuals will be included for fixed monetary penalties and variable monetary penalties (including variable monetary penalty undertakings and non-compliance penalties). For Climate Change Civil Penalties, addresses of individuals will not be included.
**Names and addresses of individuals will not be included